Devereux Digitals

Web Applications & Custom Software4 min read

Build or buy? A framework for deciding

Compare custom and ready made software on cost, speed, flexibility, ownership and risk, and learn how to choose the right investment for your business.

For: Decision makers weighing a software investment

Lorenzo DevereuxFounder & CEO, Devereux Digitals

A balanced scale with a boxed software package on one side and a custom crafted glowing component on the other.

Few technology decisions feel as big as choosing between building custom software and buying a ready made product. Both can be the right answer. Both can be expensive mistakes when chosen for the wrong reasons.

The useful question isn’t which is better in general, but which is the better investment for a particular process in your business.

The comparison

AspectReady madeCustom
Time to startDays or weeksWeeks to months
Upfront costLowHigher
Ongoing costSubscriptions, often per userHosting and maintenance
Fit to your processYou adapt to itBuilt around you
OwnershipVendor controls roadmapYou control the product
Competitive advantageSame as competitorsCan be unique
Custom vs ready made software

When ready made wins

  • The process is standard, like accounting, payroll or email.
  • You need something working this month.
  • Your team is small and your needs are simple.
  • A good product exists that fits most of your needs without workarounds.

When custom wins

  • Your process is unique or a source of competitive advantage.
  • You run several tools plus spreadsheets to do one job.
  • Per user subscription costs are growing quickly with your team.
  • You need tight integration between systems, or customer facing functionality.
  • You want to own the product, or even sell it to others.

Think in total cost of ownership

Compare costs over three to five years. For ready made software, include subscriptions as your team grows, add ons, integration tools and the time spent on workarounds. For custom software, include the build, hosting, maintenance and improvements.

A simple decision framework

  1. Is it standard?If the process is the same everywhere, buy.
  2. Does a good product fit 80% or more?If so, buy and integrate.
  3. Is it a competitive advantage?If so, consider building.
  4. Compare five year costInclude workarounds and growth, not just licence fees.
  5. Start smallIf building, prove the value with a focused first version.

The hybrid approach

Most businesses end up with a mix: proven products for standard functions, connected by integrations, plus custom software where it creates the most value. That balance gives you speed where it matters and control where it counts.

  1. Ready made CRM
  2. Ready made accounting
  3. Integrations
  4. Custom portal or app
  5. Unified operations
A typical hybrid setup

Illustrative example: a logistics company weighing its options

Imagine a regional logistics company choosing a system to manage deliveries. Accounting, HR and email are standard, so it buys proven ready made products for those. Route planning, driver allocation and proof of delivery, however, are central to how it competes on reliability.

Comparing five year costs, a ready made delivery platform would require per driver subscriptions that rise with fleet size, plus workarounds for specific customer requirements. A custom platform would cost more upfront but fit the process exactly, integrate with the accounting system and give customers a branded tracking experience.

The company would likely choose a hybrid: buy the standard tools, and build the delivery platform that sets it apart.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Comparing only first year costs.
  • Building custom software for standard functions.
  • Ignoring lock in and per user pricing growth.
  • Choosing a development partner without checking support and documentation.

How to measure success

Compare total cost of ownership over time, hours spent on workarounds, how well each option supports your growth and the impact on customer experience.

Revisit the decision periodically. A ready made product that fitted well at ten users may not at fifty, and the reverse can also be true.

Your action checklist

  1. Separate standard processes from differentiating ones.
  2. Check whether a product fits most of your needs.
  3. Estimate five year total cost for both options.
  4. Consider integration requirements.
  5. Confirm ownership and support terms.
  6. Start custom work with a focused first version.

Questions to ask before you start

  • Is this process standard or a source of advantage?
  • Does a product fit most of our needs without workarounds?
  • What will it cost over five years?
  • Who will maintain it, and do we own it?

Tools and technologies

  • HubSpot
  • Xero
  • Shopify
  • Next.js
  • PostgreSQL
  • Zapier or Make

Frequently asked questions

Conclusion

Buy where you’re like everyone else. Build where you’re different. Judge both on total cost over time and how well they fit the way you work.

Back to Custom Software guides

More from Insights & Guides.

All guides